Category: Leadership

Are We Measuring What We Truly Value in Education?

By Jonny Wathen, CEO, TransforMATive

[Dr Ahmed Shaban, Sharjah Private Education Authority (SPEA), GESS – Dubai 2026]

One of the most thought-provoking questions I have heard recently in education is a deceptively simple one: what does success look like for a young person several years after they leave school?

It immediately takes us beyond examination results, qualifications and many of the measures that traditionally dominate our education systems. Academic attainment matters and always will, but is it enough?

If our ambition is to prepare young people not simply to succeed in school, but to thrive in an uncertain and rapidly changing world, then perhaps we need to think more deeply about what we actually mean by educational success.

That was one of my strongest reflections from a recent keynote exploring how education systems might move beyond a narrow focus on attainment towards a broader understanding of the knowledge, skills, competencies and values young people need for the future.

From what young people know to what they can do

Education has traditionally been very good at measuring knowledge. We can assess whether a student understands mathematics, science, history or language. We can test recall, comprehension and subject knowledge with increasing levels of sophistication.

But knowledge is only one part of the picture.

Young people also need to be able to apply what they know. They need to think critically, communicate effectively, solve problems, navigate uncertainty, work with people who may have very different experiences and perspectives, and make responsible decisions.

The difference between knowing something and being able to use that knowledge effectively is increasingly important and being able to apply that knowledge meaningfully is increasingly significant.

Understanding leadership, for example, is very different from demonstrating responsible leadership. Knowing the principles of communication is different from listening carefully, adapting to an audience and expressing an idea clearly.

Education therefore has a responsibility not only to develop knowledge, but also to create opportunities for young people to practise, demonstrate and refine these wider capabilities. The keynote made this distinction particularly clearly.

Values matter too

There is another dimension that is sometimes harder to articulate, which is values.

Education does not take place in a cultural or moral vacuum. Every school, trust and education system makes choices about what it considers important, whether that is responsibility, respect, tolerance, integrity, service, curiosity, compassion or ambition.

Different communities will express these values in different ways, and context matters. But if our educational mission includes developing young people who can contribute positively to their communities and wider society, then values cannot simply sit within a mission statement.

They need to be visible in the lived experience of education.

That means leaders need to think carefully about the relationship between curriculum, culture, pedagogy and the behaviours we model as adults.

The challenge is not writing the framework

Many organisations already have versions of this thinking. Graduate profiles, learner attributes, character frameworks, trust values and personal development strategies can all be valuable.

But writing the framework is the easy part.

The much harder question is what actually changes because it exists.

If we say that critical thinking matters, where are students given meaningful opportunities to practise it? If we value communication, where do students learn to listen, challenge constructively and express ideas confidently? If adaptability matters, how do we create opportunities for students to experience uncertainty and solve unfamiliar problems? If responsibility matters, where are young people trusted with genuine responsibility?

This is where strategy becomes pedagogy.

Embedding broader competencies requires professional learning, curriculum thinking, experiential opportunities and a willingness to reconsider the role of both teacher and learner.

Dr Ahmed Shaban’s keynote was particularly clear that meaningful change requires alignment between educational ambition, teaching practice, professional development and assessment.

Measuring what we value

Perhaps the idea that stayed with me most was this: are we measuring what we truly value, or are we simply valuing what we already know how to measure?

It is an uncomfortable but important question.

Education systems naturally focus on measurable outcomes. That is understandable. Leaders, boards, governments and communities need evidence that education is effective.

But measurement shapes behaviour.

What we measure influences what receives attention. What receives attention influences where time and resources are invested. Over time, those measures can begin to define what an organisation believes success actually means.

That is why assessment and accountability matter so much.

If we claim that creativity, communication, resilience, character or critical thinking are important, but never meaningfully seek evidence of their development, then we risk creating a disconnect between our stated mission and our operational priorities.

The challenge is not to create another set of simplistic scores or another dashboard. Complex human capabilities should not automatically be reduced to metrics.

Instead, perhaps the opportunity is to think more intelligently about evidence. What can students demonstrate? What can teachers observe? What might projects, portfolios, reflection, performance, participation and experience tell us? How might technology help us identify patterns without replacing professional judgement?

Just as importantly, how can we do this without creating another layer of unnecessary workload?

The keynote made an important distinction between collecting data for accountability and collecting evidence that can genuinely support educational improvement.

The opportunity for data and AI

This has significant implications for digital strategy.

For many education organisations, data maturity has historically meant becoming better at reporting attainment, attendance, behaviour, finance and operational performance. Those datasets remain essential, but perhaps the next stage is to ask whether our understanding of learners can become richer.

Could data help us identify emerging needs earlier? Could technology give students greater ownership of their learning? Could artificial intelligence help teachers see patterns that might otherwise remain hidden? Could we develop more personalised support based on a broader understanding of the learner?

Potentially.

But there is an important principle here.

Technology should serve the educational ambition, not define it.

That becomes increasingly important as AI capabilities continue to develop. The question should not simply be what the technology can do, but what problem we are trying to solve and whether using technology genuinely improves the experience or outcome for the learner.

A challenge for England

There is an obvious tension for education leaders in England.

Many schools and trusts already articulate ambitions that extend well beyond academic attainment. They talk about character, citizenship, personal development, employability, inclusion, leadership and preparing young people for life.

Yet the external accountability environment remains heavily influenced by a relatively narrow set of measures.

That does not mean leaders should ignore those measures. Academic outcomes matter enormously, particularly because strong educational outcomes remain closely connected to future opportunity.

But perhaps the challenge is to resist allowing externally measured outcomes to become the entirety of our internal definition of success.

Schools, trusts and governing boards have an opportunity to ask a much broader question: what does an educated young person look like when they leave us?

And then, perhaps more importantly, how would we know whether we had achieved that?

That feels like a genuinely strategic conversation.

A global question

The same challenge exists internationally.

There is increasing interest across education systems in competencies, learner profiles, future skills and broader definitions of success. But there is unlikely to be one universal answer.

Education is deeply connected to culture, community and national identity. A successful approach therefore cannot simply be copied from one education system into another.

What we can share are the questions.

What capabilities will young people need? Which values matter within our communities? How should pedagogy evolve? What evidence would help us understand learner development? What role should technology play? How do we maintain academic rigour while broadening our understanding of success?

International collaboration becomes particularly powerful when it helps us challenge our own assumptions rather than simply importing someone else’s solutions.

Questions for education leaders

As I reflected on the keynote, there were a number of questions I found myself coming back to.

If we met our students several years after they left us, what would make us believe their education had been successful?

Does our current definition of success reflect our stated educational mission?

Are we developing transferable capabilities as intentionally as we develop subject knowledge?

Where do students have opportunities to apply what they know in authentic situations?

Are our values evident in everyday educational practice, or primarily in our communications?

What are we measuring simply because it is easy to measure?

What important things do we value but currently struggle to evidence?

And how could data, technology and AI help us understand learners more holistically without reducing them to metrics?

These are not easy questions, but they are increasingly important ones.

Beyond grades

Academic success should never become unimportant.

The challenge is not to replace attainment, but to broaden the definition of educational success around it.

Education should develop knowledge, but it should also develop judgement, confidence, curiosity, responsibility, adaptability, communication and the ability to think independently.

Perhaps most importantly, it should help young people develop the confidence and capability to navigate a world that none of us can predict with certainty.

For education leaders, the challenge is therefore not deciding whether these things matter. Most of us already believe they do.

The real challenge is ensuring that our curriculum, teaching, assessment, data, technology and leadership decisions genuinely reflect that belief.

Because perhaps the most important question is still the simplest:

Are we measuring what we value, or have we gradually learned to value what we measure?

We Live in Exciting Times: Reflections on Leadership, Technology and the Future of Education

By Jonny Wathen, CEO, TransforMATive

One phrase from a recent keynote by Pam Mundy at GESS Dubai has stayed with me:

“We live in exciting times.”

It is easy to describe the current period in education as uncertain, challenging or disruptive. All of those things are true. But they are not the whole story.

Across education, we are also witnessing extraordinary levels of innovation, investment, technological development and international collaboration. New ideas are travelling between systems more quickly than ever before. Artificial intelligence is challenging assumptions about teaching, learning, knowledge and expertise. Leaders are connecting across borders to compare approaches and question practices that may previously have gone unchallenged.

For me, that makes this an incredibly exciting time to be involved in education.

But technological progress alone will not determine whether this period ultimately improves education.

Leadership will.

Education is reaching a tipping point

There is a sense that education is approaching a significant inflection point.

Some of that is driven by technology, particularly artificial intelligence. Some is economic. Some reflects changing expectations from children, families, employers and governments. And some comes from our increasing ability to look beyond our own systems and learn from others.

What particularly resonated with me, while spending time in Dubai was the scale of ambition.

Dubai has developed into an important international meeting point for education. Leaders, schools, governments, investors, technology companies and researchers are arriving from different parts of the world, each bringing different experiences and perspectives.

That creates an opportunity that goes far beyond simply showcasing new products or technology.

It allows us to ask better questions.

Why do we organise education in the way that we do?

Which assumptions are genuinely evidence-based and which are simply inherited?

What can England learn from the UAE, Sweden, the United States or other systems?

And perhaps equally importantly, what should we choose not to replicate?

International collaboration is at its most valuable when it creates curiosity rather than conformity.

Technology gives us answers. Leadership still requires judgement.

Artificial intelligence is perhaps the most obvious example of the change taking place around us.

Access to information is no longer the constraint it once was.

Children, parents, teachers and leaders can increasingly access sophisticated explanations, recommendations and analysis instantly.

But information is not expertise.

And an answer is not necessarily the right answer.

That distinction is increasingly important.

AI can help us analyse information, generate possibilities, automate processes and challenge our thinking. In education, its potential is significant.

But it does not remove the need for professional judgement.

If anything, it increases it.

As the volume of information available to us grows, our ability to evaluate that information, understand context, recognise bias and make responsible decisions becomes increasingly important.

Perhaps we therefore need to think not only about artificial intelligence, but also about what we might call alternative intelligence.

Experience.

Wisdom.

Professional expertise.

Empathy.

Context.

Human relationships.

Moral judgement.

These are not things we should position in opposition to technology. The most powerful future is likely to emerge when human and artificial intelligence complement one another.

The challenge for education leaders is designing organisations where that happens intentionally.

Leadership itself is changing

One of the most interesting ideas raised was the concept of extreme leadership.

I found the idea particularly compelling because the expectations placed upon education leaders are changing rapidly.

Leadership development has traditionally prepared people to operate within relatively stable systems. We learn about strategy, finance, governance, people management, curriculum, operations and organisational improvement.

All of those capabilities remain essential.

But leaders are now also being asked to navigate technological disruption, cybersecurity, artificial intelligence, data ethics, workforce transformation, growing public expectations and global uncertainty.

Many of the decisions we face have no established precedent.

There is no handbook for every situation.

That means leadership increasingly requires the confidence to operate where the answer is not immediately obvious.

It requires curiosity.

It requires humility.

It requires conviction.

And sometimes it requires the courage to make a decision before perfect information is available.

The strongest leaders will not necessarily be those who claim to have all the answers. They may instead be those who create organisations capable of continually asking better questions.

Authenticity matters more as complexity increases

In periods of rapid change, values become increasingly important.

When there are dozens of possible directions an organisation could take, leaders need something against which those choices can be tested.

For me, some of the most important leadership questions are often the simplest:

Does this genuinely improve education?

Does this improve the experience or outcomes of children and young people?

Does this align with our values?

Would we be comfortable explaining this decision publicly?

Technology can make organisations faster.

Data can make organisations better informed.

AI can make organisations more productive.

But none of those things determine what an organisation should value.

That remains a leadership responsibility.

Authenticity and integrity therefore become increasingly important. Leaders will sometimes need to challenge fashionable ideas, resist pressure or acknowledge uncertainty.

There will be occasions when the most responsible decision is to move quickly.

There will also be occasions when leadership means saying: not yet.

Purpose and commercial sustainability can coexist

Another theme that deserves greater discussion is the relationship between social impact and commercial success.

Within education, we can sometimes be uncomfortable talking about profit, investment or commercial models.

That caution is understandable. Education exists to serve children and communities, not markets.

But commercial/financial sustainability and social purpose do not have to be opposing ideas.

The best organisations should be capable of delivering meaningful social impact while also operating sustainably.

Innovation requires investment.

High-quality people require investment.

Research, product development, infrastructure and support all require investment.

The question should therefore not simply be whether an organisation generates profit.

More important questions are how that value is created, where it is reinvested, whether outcomes genuinely improve and whether the relationship between provider and education institution remains ethical and transparent.

For suppliers working with education, commercial success should be a consequence of creating genuine value rather than the objective around which everything else revolves.

That balance is important to maintain.

What might this mean for leaders in England?

England has an education system with considerable strengths, but we can sometimes become overly focused on the constraints within our own environment.

Policy.

Funding.

Accountability.

Inspection.

Workforce pressures.

All are significant.

But international conversations remind us that the structures we operate within are not inevitable.

Other countries make different choices.

They organise schools differently.

They approach technology differently.

They develop teachers differently.

They fund innovation differently.

They define success differently.

For leaders in England, there is enormous value in occasionally stepping outside the system intellectually and asking what education might look like if we were designing parts of it today.

That does not mean importing another country’s model wholesale.

Context matters enormously.

But it does mean remaining curious enough to challenge assumptions.

And what might this mean globally?

The same principle works in the opposite direction.

There is no single global model of excellent education.

Systems reflect their history, culture, economy, geography and social expectations.

The opportunity therefore lies in collaboration without assuming uniformity.

International education networks should not simply become mechanisms for exporting practices from one country to another.

They should become places where leaders compare perspectives.

Where assumptions are challenged.

Where evidence is examined.

And where ideas are adapted intelligently to local context.

We should learn from one another without losing sight of the communities we actually serve.

Eight considerations for education leaders

As I reflected on the conversation, I found myself returning to eight questions that feel increasingly important for leaders, whether they are working in England or elsewhere in the world:

  1. Are we preparing our organisations for technological change, or simply reacting to it?
  2. Do our people understand the difference between access to information and genuine expertise?
  3. Are we developing human judgement alongside artificial intelligence?
  4. Which assumptions within our education system should we be willing to challenge?
  5. Are our commercial and technology partnerships genuinely creating educational value?
  6. Do our leaders have permission to experiment, question and occasionally get things wrong?
  7. Are we actively learning from education systems beyond our own borders?
  8. When difficult decisions arise, are children and young people still at the centre of them?

That final question is perhaps the most important.

Children must remain the constant

Technology will change.

Governments will change.

Policies will change.

Organisational structures will change.

The tools available to educators will undoubtedly become more sophisticated.

But the fundamental responsibility of education leaders remains remarkably consistent.

We are here to create better opportunities for children and young people.

That purpose provides an important anchor when everything else feels as though it is moving.

The future of education will not be determined simply by which organisations adopt AI fastest, deploy the most technology or generate the most data.

It will be shaped by the quality of the decisions leaders make with those capabilities.

By their judgement.

By their integrity.

By their willingness to collaborate.

And by their determination to advocate for children.

That is why I left the conversation feeling optimistic.

We undoubtedly live in interesting times.

But perhaps the better description is the one I heard in Dubai:

We live in exciting times.

Our responsibility as leaders is to make sure we do something worthwhile with them.

Belonging and Attainment: What DfE Research Reveals

A pupil who doesn’t feel they belong at school is, on average, doing worse. Not slightly worse, but close to a full GCSE grade worse across their entire set of results.  That’s the headline from research commissioned by the Department for Education. For trust leaders, it provides some of the clearest evidence yet that wellbeing and academic attainment are not separate agendas competing for the same time, resource, and budget. They are fundamentally connected.

A central focus of the TransforMATive Digital Leadership Summit is how multi-academy trusts move beyond siloed systems and build genuinely connected intelligence. This research challenges executive teams to look closely at their own digital ecosystems. The DfE study analysed survey responses from 4,763 pupils in 165 English schools, linking their answers about school belonging directly to their Key Stage 4 attainment data. In doing so, it connects what pupils say about their lived experience of school with their measured academic outcomes demonstrating why digital and data strategies must do the same.

A GCSE grade’s worth of difference

The research measured pupils’ sense of belonging against their Attainment 8 scores, the metric that averages a pupil’s results across eight GCSE subjects. After accounting for prior attainment, pupil characteristics and bullying, pupils who strongly disagreed that they belonged at school scored 7.72 points lower on average than those who strongly agreed, a gap equivalent to almost a full GCSE grade across all eight subjects. Pupils who simply disagreed, without feeling strongly about it, scored 4.02 points lower. The DfE is careful to note that this shows an association rather than proven cause and effect, but the scale of the gap is hard to ignore.

Which pupils report lower levels of school belonging?

The same research found clear disparities in reported belonging. Girls, pupils eligible for free school meals (FSM) and pupils with SEND were less likely to say they felt they belonged at school than their peers, although the differences for FSM and SEND were not statistically significant at the 5% level.

  • 58% of girls felt they belonged at school, against 66% of boys
  • 58% of pupils eligible for free school meals felt they belonged, against 63% of other pupils
  • 56% of pupils with SEND felt they belonged, against 63% of pupils without

These are exactly the groups schools already spend the most pastoral effort trying to support. In light of these findings, having a reliable way to measure belonging, rather than infer it, more useful than ever.

The government’s approach to measuring school belonging

The findings add weight to a direction of travel already set out in the DfE’s Every Child Achieving and Thriving white paper, which sets out an explicit ambition: every school monitoring pupils’ sense of belonging and engagement by 2029, through a planned pupil engagement framework, up from around 60% of schools doing so today. That ambition isn’t sitting on a shelf: in April, the first major piece of wellbeing-focused legislation – The Children’s Wellbeing and Schools Act 2026 – received royal assent. While the Act doesn’t put wellbeing monitoring on a statutory footing itself (that’s still due through the separate pupil engagement framework), it shows a government moving from writing ambitions down to legislating for them. This legislation follows the same logic already built into Ofsted’s current framework, which grades schools on ‘personal development & wellbeing’ as a standalone judgement area.

Put together, the direction of travel is clear. Wellbeing monitoring is moving from good practice to expectation. School leaders can be getting ahead of expectation and embedding best-practice before it’s required by ensuring they have a reliable way to track wellbeing today.

What it means for FE and training providers

Attainment 8 is a schools-only measure, so this particular study doesn’t speak directly to post-16 outcomes. However, there is a parallel shift in post-16 inspection towards making learner wellbeing, belonging and participation more explicit. Under Ofsted’s renewed framework, ‘participation and development’ is a graded evaluation area, and inspectors consider whether learners belong, feel valued and are supported to thrive.

Separate research from the Association of Colleges found that 88% of responding colleges identified poor mental health as one of the top three reasons for poor student attendance in 2023/24, up from 50% before the pandemic. The 2024/25 survey paints a starker picture still: 90% of colleges reported an increase in 16-18 year-olds disclosing mental health issues, and 74% reported an increase in suicide ideation in the same age group over the previous year. The AoC have laid out a Mental Health Charter, which sets out standards colleges can work towards.

These data points confirm that the underlying question – “do you actually know how your learners are doing, beyond attendance and grades?” – is the key question to be asking.

You already have a way to measure this

This is precisely the question the CENTURY Wellbeing Tool was built to answer, and it’s included in every CENTURY subscription at no extra cost. Built on the validated Student Subjective Wellbeing Questionnaire, it takes a learner under five minutes to complete and reports back across five domains: connectedness, academic efficacy, joy of learning, educational purpose and safety. Reporting is immediate and confidential, with safety flags for anyone who may need immediate support.

You can run the questionnaire as often as you like: our recommendation is to do a termly check in with the tool to get a picture of belonging alongside the academic data you already track on CENTURY. We covered how the tool works in more detail in our article Supporting Every Learner.

Government policy is inevitably heading towards a world where every school and college can answer, with evidence, whether their pupils and learners feel they belong. However, what a school or trust does with a term’s worth of data is the part that actually moves the dial, and it is a question worth returning to on its own.

For now, the practical starting point is ensuring you are capturing that data seamlessly. CENTURY customers already have the Wellbeing Tool to do this built directly into their platform at no extra cost, allowing them to view a picture of belonging alongside the academic data they already track.

The answer to better trust-wide insight is not always more technology; sometimes, it is making what we already have work better together.   

Connected Intelligence with TransforMATive & CENTURY Tech

This challenge of linking strategic ambition with practical, trust-wide delivery lies at the core of CENTURY Tech’s involvement in the TransforMATive Digital Leadership Summit at the University of Leeds. 

Through CENTURY’s “Connected by Design?” digital leadership health check framework, trust leaders can systematically evaluate how strategy, people, systems, and data work together to drive meaningful impact across their schools.

Connect: Creating the Space to Think

As part of the preparation for TransforMATive LIVE: Sweden, our leadership exchange taking place in December, I recently had the opportunity to spend a few hours in Stockholm.

Sweden feels like a particularly relevant place for this conversation. It has a long history of digitalisation in education, strong digital infrastructure and skills, and a well-developed EdTech ecosystem. Around nine in ten secondary pupils have access to a school-provided digital device, while the European Commission continues to describe Sweden as having a strong digital ecosystem, high-quality connectivity and a highly digitally skilled population. Digital Strategy

For me, that makes Sweden interesting not simply because technology is present, but because it provides an opportunity to explore what happens after digital adoption. How do digitally mature organisations make better choices about what technology should enable, where it should sit and, increasingly, where it should not?

That question stayed with me as I experienced Stockholm.

From the Vasa Museum and Djurgården, across the waterfront and Skeppsholmen, through to the Royal Palace and the streets of Gamla Stan, what struck me was the contrast.

The Vasa itself provides an extraordinary leadership lesson. It was an ambitious seventeenth-century Swedish warship which sank in Stockholm harbour just minutes into its maiden voyage in 1628, before being recovered from the seabed 333 years later. Vasa Museum

For me, its story is a reminder that progress is not simply about ambition, resources or technical capability.

It is also about judgement.

Challenge.

And whether an organisation creates the conditions for good decisions to be made.

Elsewhere, Stockholm brings together history, culture, design and modern public life in a way that feels intentional and connected rather than hurried.

That feels increasingly relevant to leadership in the age of AI.

AI gives us the ability to move faster, process more information and automate increasing amounts of work.

But speed and productivity are not the same thing as progress.

If every efficiency simply creates capacity for another report, another task, another analysis or another decision, we risk replacing workload with work intensity.

For MAT leaders, that distinction matters.

The promise of digital transformation should not simply be that we can fit more into the working day.

It should be that we can make better decisions about what deserves our time in the first place.

That is why I increasingly think head space is becoming a strategic resource.

Leaders need space to think.

Space to challenge assumptions.

Space to make connections between things that might otherwise remain separate.

Space to listen to different perspectives.

And, occasionally, space to decide that something does not need to be done at all.

This thinking sits at the heart of the Connect theme for our Digital Leadership Summit and our wider TransforMATive community, including TransforMATive LIVE.

Connect is not simply about bringing people together.

It is about creating the conditions for reflection, challenge and shared understanding.

It is about stepping outside the rhythm of everyday operational leadership long enough to ask whether we are solving the right problems, whether technology is genuinely helping and whether activity remains connected to organisational purpose.

These moments deliberately introduce a little useful friction.

They allow us to listen.

To compare experiences.

To question what has become normal.

To understand how other organisations are approaching similar challenges.

And to consider where technology can genuinely add value, rather than simply add pace.

For me, that leaves three increasingly important questions for MAT leaders:

What can technology enable us to do?

But also:

What should we do differently because the technology now exists?

And perhaps most importantly:

What should remain fundamentally human?

As trusts mature digitally, those questions become more important, not less.

The greatest value technology creates may not always be additional capacity to do more.

Sometimes it is the space to think more clearly about what matters, what we can stop doing and what should come next.

Perhaps that is one of the most important forms of Connect of all.

Jonny Wathen
CEO, TransforMATive

TransforMATive Insights brings together learning from our work with multi-academy trusts, sector leaders and partners, informed by the latest research and emerging evidence, to explore the issues, opportunities and practical choices shaping digital leadership across education.

Relational Architecture: Design the Spaces Between the Boxes

Most conversations about operating models begin with structure.

Who reports to whom? What sits centrally? What remains within schools? Where does responsibility ultimately sit?

Those questions matter. But increasingly, I think some of the more important organisational challenges sit between the boxes.

Take AI governance.

A trust can appoint a senior responsible officer, publish an AI policy and establish a clear approval process.

Structurally, everything can look sensible.

But what happens when a teacher identifies a new use case?

When should the DPO become involved?

When does curriculum leadership need to engage?

Who speaks to procurement?

How does learning from one school reach another?

And what happens when an issue crosses technology, safeguarding, education, data protection and finance at the same time?

The answer rarely sits neatly within a single role or reporting line.

That is relational architecture.

It is the way people, teams and responsibilities connect around the work that actually needs to happen.

This feels particularly relevant to our Connect theme for this year’s Digital Leadership Summit.

As trusts grow and become more digitally mature, the challenge is not simply to design clearer structures. It is to ensure that the relationships between those structures are equally deliberate.

Evidence around organisational decision making consistently suggests that allocating roles and responsibilities is only part of the answer. Effective organisations also need clarity about how those roles interact, where information moves, who needs to be involved and how disagreement is resolved.

The same is true of organisational networks. Performance is shaped not only by formal hierarchy, but by the connections that allow knowledge, challenge and expertise to move across traditional boundaries.

For MAT leaders, that creates another set of questions.

Who needs to connect with whom?

About what?

How frequently?

What information should move between them?

Where does a decision ultimately sit?

And what happens when there is legitimate disagreement?

These questions become even more important in a trust model, where local agency and organisational coherence will always need to coexist.

The ambition should not be to centralise every decision or create another layer of process.

It should be to design the connections that allow the right decisions to be made, by the right people, with the right information.

That is why Connect is not simply about collaboration.

It is about organisational design.

It is about recognising that the quality of a trust’s operating model is shaped as much by the relationships between functions, schools and leaders as it is by the structures themselves.

So the provocation I would offer MAT leaders is simple:

If you removed every box from your organisational chart and left only the connections between them, would there still be an operating model?

If not, we may have designed the organisation, but not yet designed how it actually works.

Jonny Wathen
CEO, TransforMATive

TransforMATive Insights brings together learning from our work with multi-academy trusts, sector leaders and partners, informed by the latest research and emerging evidence, to explore the issues, opportunities and practical choices shaping digital leadership across education.

Social Network Theory: The Organisation You Cannot See on the Structure Chart

We can describe a multi-academy trust very neatly.

There is an executive team. Central functions. Regional structures. Schools. Committees. Reporting lines and accountability.

But that is not necessarily how the organisation actually works.

Knowledge rarely moves only through formal structures. Advice, influence, challenge and problem solving often travel through relationships that sit alongside the organisation chart. Some are visible. Many are not.

That matters.

Research into social networks has consistently shown the importance of connections between people who would otherwise sit in separate groups. It also highlights the value of individuals who bridge gaps between different networks, helping information, knowledge and opportunity move across organisational boundaries.

Applied to a multi-academy trust, the implications are significant.

Two headteachers might occupy exactly the same position on an organisational chart, with the same reporting relationship and broadly similar responsibilities.

But their experience of the organisation can be completely different.

One may speak regularly with five other heads, have strong relationships with colleagues in the central team, know who to contact when something goes wrong and feel confident asking for advice.

Another may primarily interact with their own school and formal line manager.

Structurally, they are identical. Relationally, they are very different.

As trusts grow, I think one of the most valuable leadership exercises is therefore to understand the network that actually exists.

Where does advice really come from?

Who do colleagues contact when they need help rather than when the process tells them to?

Who connects education with technology, finance with operations, or schools with the central team?

Where is important knowledge repeatedly held by one individual?

And which colleagues have quietly become critical points of organisational dependency simply because they are trusted, connected and know how things really work?

This becomes particularly important as trusts mature digitally.

Technology can make communication easier and information more accessible, but it does not automatically create meaningful connection. In fact, more platforms, more channels and more information can just as easily create additional noise.

The objective should not be maximum connectivity.

It should be purposeful connectivity.

For our Digital Leadership Summit, that is what makes Connect much more than an invitation to network.

Connect is an organisational design challenge.

It is about understanding how knowledge, trust and influence move through the trust. It is about ensuring that expertise is not trapped within individual schools, teams or roles. And it is about creating deliberate connections between the people responsible for education, operations, finance, people, data and technology.

Digital maturity increasingly depends upon this.

A trust can have excellent systems and still struggle if the relationships between those systems, teams and decisions are weak. Equally, strong networks can help organisations adapt more quickly, share practice more effectively and make better use of the expertise that already exists within them.

Perhaps the most useful question is this:

If we removed every formal reporting line from the organisation chart and instead mapped where knowledge, trust and influence actually flowed, what would our organisation look like?

And, more importantly, is that the organisation we intended to build?

Jonny Wathen
CEO, TransforMATive

TransforMATive Insights brings together learning from our work with multi-academy trusts, sector leaders and partners, informed by the latest research and emerging evidence, to explore the issues, opportunities and practical choices shaping digital leadership across education.

Connect: What digital leadership now requires

Connect Before You Automate

For several years, one of the promises of digital transformation has been that technology will give us time back.

AI makes that promise feel more achievable than ever. Reports can be drafted in minutes. Information can be synthesised almost instantly. Analysis that once required hours can happen before the next meeting begins.

But for leaders, there is a more important question:

What happens to the time we save?

Across our work with multi-academy trusts, we are increasingly seeing a tension between efficiency and intensity. When technology makes something quicker, the natural response can be to do more of it. Another report. Another scenario. Another analysis. Another meeting.

The risk is that we use technology to accelerate an operating model that was already too busy.

Efficiency can very quickly become intensity.

This matters because digital leadership is not simply about introducing better tools. It is about creating the organisational conditions in which technology genuinely improves the experience of pupils, staff and communities.

If AI reduces the production of a board report from three hours to thirty minutes, do we consciously return some of that capacity to colleagues? Do we create space for professional judgement, relationships and reflection? Or do we simply commission more activity because the capacity now exists?

That is why the theme of this year’s TransforMATive Digital Leadership Summit begins with Connect, before we move to Enable and ultimately Lead.

Connect is about more than technology.

It is about connecting digital investment to organisational purpose. Connecting strategy to the realities of delivery. Connecting leaders across education, operations, finance, people, data and technology. And, increasingly, connecting trusts with one another so that learning, challenge and innovation can be shared across the system.

Before we automate a process, we should ask whether the process still needs to exist.

Before we introduce another platform, we should understand the problem we are trying to solve.

Before we use AI to increase capacity, we should decide deliberately what we want to do with the capacity it creates.

And before we pursue the next technology opportunity, we should be clear about what should remain distinctly human.

For MAT leaders, the opportunity is not simply to make an already busy organisation move faster.

It is to redesign the organisation around what matters.

That requires connection first.

TransforMATive Insights draws upon our ongoing work with multi-academy trusts, sector leaders and partners, alongside the latest research and emerging evidence, to identify the themes, challenges and opportunities shaping digital leadership across education.

The Vehicle Is Not the Driver

Why Seeing Teaching Clearly Is Not the Same as Improving It

Written by Danielle Finlay, October 2026

Abstract

Every conference about the future of education now promises greater visibility: better dashboards, richer data and more connected systems that help leaders see what is happening in classrooms. Written for a conference exploring how leadership, technology and organisational practice can combine to transform education, this article argues that visibility is a beginning, not a destination. Drawing on research into judgement, organisational culture and school improvement, alongside an anonymised leadership experience from a multi-academy trust, it considers how greater visibility can support better decisions, but can also accelerate weak ones when seeing is mistaken for understanding. The central claim is simple: technology is the vehicle. Whether that vehicle moves an organisation towards genuine improvement depends on the culture, judgement and behaviour of the leaders driving it. The article proposes a discipline, Know, Interpret, Act, Learn, through which visibility can become wiser rather than merely faster decision-making.

Introduction: The Question Behind the Conference

I am writing this a few weeks before I stand in front of a room of trust chief executives and system leaders at the TransforMATive Digital Leadership Summit, an event exploring how leadership, technology and organisational practice can combine to transform education. I believe technology can play a powerful part in that transformation, or I would not have spent the last several years of my career engaging with, and more recently leading, a platform designed to support it. But I want to use this piece to challenge one assumption that can sit too easily alongside conversations about educational technology: that greater visibility necessarily leads to better decisions.

Visibility is not the same as improvement. Seeing more of teaching does not automatically mean understanding it better. A sector that is becoming more instrumented, more dashboarded and more data-rich is not thereby becoming more insightful. In some organisations I have worked in and with, the more visible teaching became, the more important it was for leaders to slow down their interpretation, precisely because visibility arrived faster than the judgement required to use it well.

This is not an argument against technology. It is an argument about what technology is for, and what it is not for. Technology is the vehicle. It can connect evidence, expose patterns and move an organisation somewhere. It cannot decide where that organisation should go, or whether what has become visible is sufficient to justify action. Those decisions, and the culture in which they are made, belong to leaders.

That is the argument of this piece: visibility must come before judgement, but visibility is a beginning, not an answer. I will draw on research into decision-making, organisational culture and school improvement, and on my own experience leading through this tension, to make the case for a discipline that converts what technology reveals into something worth calling insight.

The Familiar Shape of the Problem

Ask any group of trust leaders whether they lack information about teaching, and the answer is almost never yes. Most schools and trusts I have worked in are rich in evidence: lesson visits, book looks, pupil voice, CPD logs, appraisal targets, learning walks and coaching records. The problem is rarely a shortage of activity intended to improve teaching. It is more often a problem of connection and interpretation.

Four patterns recur with striking regularity across contexts that otherwise look very different.

The first is disconnection. Lesson visits happen in one system, feedback lives in another, CPD is planned in a third, and appraisal sits in a fourth. Each activity is defensible in isolation. Collectively, they do not always add up to a coherent account of what the organisation understands about its own teaching.

The second is variable interpretation. Leaders can observe the same practice and reach meaningfully different conclusions, not necessarily because any of them is wrong, but because they are applying slightly different, often unarticulated, theories of what great teaching looks like. At trust scale, that variation can become inconsistency that teachers experience as unfairness.

The third is blanket action. A leader notices a pattern, perhaps in one department or from a small number of visits, and the response becomes a whole-school programme. Precision is sacrificed for the appearance of decisiveness, while the people who most need support may receive the same generic response as everyone else.

The fourth is initiative fatigue. Activity accumulates. Frameworks are launched and then quietly superseded. Staff experience change not as progress but as churn, with another priority added before the previous one has been properly evaluated or embedded.

None of these patterns is caused by a lack of commitment. What is often missing is architecture: the connective tissue that allows one piece of evidence to inform the next, one leader’s interpretation to be tested against another’s, and one action to be evaluated before a further response is added (Fullan and Quinn, 2016; Bryk et al., 2015).

This is where the promise of education technology becomes both useful and demanding.

The Visibility Trap

The seductive version of the story goes like this: fragmentation is a data problem, and data problems have technological solutions. Bring every signal into one place, present it clearly enough, and the fog lifts. Leaders will finally see their organisation as it really is.

That promise is only half true.

Daniel Kahneman’s work on judgement offers an uncomfortable starting point. Human beings are highly susceptible to substituting a difficult question for an easier one, particularly under time pressure and when information feels abundant (Kahneman, 2011). When faced with the demanding question:

What does this tell us about practice over time and context?

It is far easier to answer a different one:

What does this snapshot suggest?

Data does not protect leaders from that substitution. It can give an answer a sense of legitimacy that intuition alone does not.

Jerry Muller’s critique of metric fixation sharpens the point. Once an indicator exists, there is a strong institutional pull towards treating it as a proxy for the complex reality it was only ever meant to represent, and then towards managing the proxy rather than the reality (Muller, 2018). A dashboard showing repeated weak drop-ins in a department can very easily become “the department with a problem”, when a slower, triangulated account might tell a more complicated story.

This is the visibility trap: seeing more can feel like understanding more, when it may simply move leaders faster, and with greater apparent authority, towards conclusions the evidence does not yet support. The clearer the picture becomes, the more disciplined leaders must be about what it allows them to say reliably.

Let me tell you how that lesson can play out in practice.

The Trust That Saw Too Much, Too Soon

A few years ago, while working across a multi-academy trust, I reviewed typicality data drawn from lesson visits across a number of schools. Something in the pattern did not sit right. Some schools with a history of weaker outcomes were showing a noticeably higher proportion of teachers evaluated as meeting the expected standard than schools with a longer record of stronger performance.

Read quickly, that looks like good news. Read against other evidence, including pupil outcomes, external validation and the longer-term trajectory of those schools, it raised a different question.

The temptation was to take the data at face value. Instead, we treated the pattern as a prompt for enquiry rather than an answer:

What does “expected standard” actually mean, in practice, across these schools?

How consistently are our leaders applying and moderating it?

Are different local contexts shaping how reassurance and accuracy are being balanced?

We commissioned a cross-school calibration process rather than a review of individual staff: joint learning walks, moderated discussion of evidence gathered through our platform, and structured professional dialogue between leaders working in contrasting contexts. What we found was not that teaching in some of our historically weaker schools had quietly become stronger than teaching in our strongest ones. It was that leaders emerging from a period of sustained difficulty had, understandably and with good intentions, adopted a more generous interpretation of what “expected” meant while trying to rebuild confidence.

This was not a failure of professionalism. It was a cultural signal about how reassurance and accuracy were being balanced under pressure, and it would have been difficult to see without the data. It would also have been easy to misread through the data alone. Had we treated the pattern as a verdict rather than a prompt for enquiry, we would have drawn the wrong conclusion at precisely the moment our confidence in the platform’s visibility was highest.

The correction was not to distrust the technology. It was to recalibrate what “expected” and “excellent” meant in practice, using shared exemplars and moderated professional dialogue, and to make clear that accuracy was not a punishment. Only when diagnosis is honest can support be targeted where it is genuinely needed (Kahneman, 2011; Wiliam, 2011).

Just as importantly, the way we approached that recalibration mattered. Leaders went into those schools to understand how the judgement had been formed, not simply to correct it. We acknowledged the context those schools had travelled through and treated the centre as a partner asking a hard question alongside them, rather than an inspectorate arriving with a verdict. That protected the trust required for the recalibration to become useful rather than defensive (Bryk and Schneider, 2002).

I share this story because it is the clearest illustration I have of the difference between visibility and understanding. The platform did exactly what it was designed to do: it made a pattern visible that might otherwise have remained hidden inside separate sets of local judgement. What it could not do was tell us what that pattern meant. That interpretation depended on leaders willing to be curious rather than reassured, and on a culture in which an uncomfortable question about our own data could be experienced as rigour rather than disloyalty.

The Vehicle and the Driver

This is where I want to return to the framing behind this piece.

Technology is the vehicle. It is genuinely capable of moving an organisation somewhere: connecting evidence that would otherwise stay scattered across notebooks, inboxes and individual memory; making patterns visible at a scale no single leader could hold in their head; and preserving a professional conversation so it does not have to be reconstructed every time a new leader joins the organisation. All of that is real, and none of it is trivial.

But a vehicle does not choose its destination, and it does not know when it has arrived somewhere true rather than somewhere merely visible. Nor does it take account of who is travelling and how they experience the journey. That is the work of leadership behaviour and the culture it creates.

Edgar Schein’s distinction between climate and culture is useful here (Schein, 2010). A new platform, however sophisticated, interacts first with the current climate around feedback, scrutiny and change. Only when leadership behaviour around that platform is consistent, visible and trusted over time does technology become part of a healthier organisational culture (Bryk and Schneider, 2002).

This is why the same technology can produce very different experiences in different organisations. Where leaders invite challenge to their own interpretation of the data and treat patterns as prompts for professional dialogue, visibility is more likely to be experienced as support. Where data is used as a verdict to be delivered, the same technology can feel like surveillance, whatever language is used to introduce it.

The determining variable is not only the sophistication of the platform. It is whether leaders have created enough psychological safety for a difficult pattern to be discussed honestly, without the person closest to the practice feeling that they must first protect themselves from what the data appears to say about them (Edmondson, 1999; Edmondson, 2019). Feedback is only developmental when it helps someone adjust their practice confidently, purposefully and without fear of judgement (Hattie and Timperley, 2007). That is a discipline of leadership behaviour, not a feature of a dashboard.

None of this is an argument for slowing the adoption of better technology. It is an argument for recognising that technology alone was never going to do the hardest part of the work. The vehicle can travel considerably faster now than it could five years ago. Whether it takes an organisation somewhere worth going still depends on who is driving and what their people have learnt to trust.

Clarity Before Technology

There is a prior question that too many organisations skip in their rush towards greater visibility, and it has little to do with data.

Before leaders attempt to measure teaching consistently, they need enough shared clarity about what they believe great teaching looks like and why. A shared pedagogical framework can support this work, but it cannot substitute for it. Codification has to follow genuine professional agreement about educational purpose, rather than creating the appearance of consensus through a rubric alone (Shulman, 1987; Biesta, 2013).

The absence of that clarity usually appears first in the everyday mechanism of feedback. Without a shared, durable understanding of what great teaching looks like here, feedback can become tied to whatever the current rubric happens to measure, episodic rather than developmental, and responsive to whichever pattern has surfaced most recently. Each individual piece of feedback may be accurate and well-intentioned, yet still fail to accumulate into a coherent direction for professional growth (Hattie and Timperley, 2007).

I have watched organisations invest heavily in visibility while remaining privately unclear about what they were trying to see. Ask ten leaders to describe great teaching in their own trust and they may give ten different answers, not because they disagree fundamentally, but because the underlying clarity has never been forced into the open. When that happens, a platform does not resolve the confusion. It scales it.

This is why I now think of technology’s most valuable early contribution not as insight, but as exposure. It makes an organisation’s existing lack of clarity visible more quickly by forcing leaders to notice when their interpretations diverge. Used well, that discomfort becomes the beginning of the real work: building the shared language and pedagogical identity on which any credible system of visibility depends (Senge, 2006).

The leadership task is therefore not to eliminate disagreement quickly. It is to create the conditions in which disagreement can be surfaced, examined and resolved well enough to create genuine shared understanding. Going slowly enough to have that argument properly is often what allows an organisation to move faster, and more consistently, afterwards.

This is how we help leaders to see clearly, act proportionately and improve deliberately.

From Judgement to Enquiry

If visibility should not be trusted to deliver its own interpretation, what discipline should leaders put in its place?

I have come to rely on a simple sequence, developed through years of exactly the mistakes described above: know, interpret, act, learn. To know is to build an increasingly reliable understanding of what is happening, while remaining honest about what the evidence cannot yet tell us. To interpret is to bring context, professional expertise and more than one perspective to that evidence before deciding what it means. To act is to respond proportionately, through coaching, professional development, further enquiry or deliberate non-intervention. To learn is to return to what happened next and let that experience refine what the organisation understands, rather than treating the original judgement as final.

The discipline lives or dies between interpretation and action. A pattern is often noticed and a response generated in the same breath, without the intervening question of what kind of response the evidence actually warrants. An isolated occurrence in one classroom is not the same evidence as a pattern repeated across a department, a phase or a trust, and treating them identically is an expensive mistake (Bryk et al., 2015).

The table below sets out the distinction I try to hold onto whenever a pattern lands on my desk.

What the Pattern IsWhat It Might WarrantWhat It Does Not Warrant
Isolated, a single observationA conversation; further evidence gathering; professional curiosityA whole-school response; a formal judgement about the individual
Repeated within one team or departmentTargeted coaching; subject-specific professional developmentImmediate trust-wide policy change
Consistent across multiple, unrelated contextsInvestigation into curriculum, systems or leadership conditionsIndividual blame; isolated coaching alone
Strong practice, recurringRecognition; sharing as a model for othersSilence; treating strength as unremarkable

None of these responses can be found in a dashboard. A platform can show a leader that a pattern exists. It cannot tell them whether that pattern reflects an isolated moment, a genuine department-level need, or a system-level condition that individual coaching alone will not resolve (Argyris and Schön, 1978). That judgement belongs to the leader willing to ask what else might explain it, and to accept that their first interpretation may be wrong.

This is, I think, one of the most important leadership skills of the next decade: not the ability to gather evidence, which our sector is rapidly becoming good at, but the discipline to ask a better question before reaching for a bigger response.

What This Means for the Trust You Lead

Everything above matters more, not less, at trust scale.

A single headteacher can, with effort, hold a reasonably complete picture of their own school in their head. A trust CEO leading many schools cannot and should not try to. The temptation at scale is to resolve that impossibility through aggregation: bring everything into one dashboard, compare schools against each other and treat variation as a problem to engineer away.

Variation between schools is not, in itself, evidence of inconsistency. Different curricula, demographics, staffing histories and stages of improvement will legitimately produce different pictures. The leadership discipline at trust level is not to remove variation, but to develop enough shared language and trust between leaders that variation can be discussed honestly rather than defended or hidden (Fullan, 2016; Spillane, 2006).

The distinction worth naming here is between aligned autonomy and enforced standardisation. Alignment belongs to the north star: a shared, codified understanding of what great teaching means and why it matters. Autonomy belongs everywhere alignment does not need to reach: the curriculum choices, staffing decisions and pace of improvement that only make sense inside a school’s own history and context. Strong trusts resist the temptation to mistake tight alignment for a licence to standardise everything beneath it. They hold the purpose firmly while allowing leaders to own their context (Fullan and Quinn, 2016).

A platform bought once and left to run will drift towards the visibility trap described earlier. No system stays calibrated to an organisation’s evolving understanding of its own teaching without ongoing leadership attention. Organisations that use visibility well treat their platform, pedagogical framework and professional judgement as things to refine together, not to configure once and consider solved (Fullan and Quinn, 2016).

A useful test is to ask four questions:

Where do our shared beliefs about great teaching and what the evidence shows genuinely agree?

Where are we confident that the north star is shared, but have not tested that belief?

What is the platform surfacing that we have not yet sat with long enough to interpret?

What question about our own teaching have we not yet thought, or dared, to ask?

Sit with whichever question makes you least comfortable. That discomfort, not the dashboard, is where the harder work of this piece begins.

Conclusion: What Are We Actually Trying to Transform?

A conference organised around transformation invites an obvious question worth asking directly: transformation of what, exactly? If it means the sophistication of our dashboards and the speed of our data, education technology is already delivering and will continue to. If it means the quality of teaching that children experience, day after day, then the sophistication of the vehicle is only one part of the answer.

Genuine transformation depends on whether leaders build the culture, shared language and discipline of enquiry that allow visibility to become insight rather than merely faster judgement. Technology can preserve professional memory, connect evidence that used to sit in separate systems and reveal patterns no single classroom visit could show. What it cannot do is decide what those patterns mean, create the psychological safety required for teachers to engage honestly with what they reveal, or replace the sometimes uncomfortable work of building a shared understanding of great teaching.

I said at the start of this piece that visibility must come before judgement. That does not mean judgement can wait indefinitely, or that leaders should hide behind further data-gathering to avoid difficult decisions. It means the quality of the judgement leaders make should never outrun the quality of the understanding on which it depends, however urgent, visible or confidently presented the information may be.

The vehicle is not the driver. As technology becomes more capable, persuasive and embedded in how we lead schools and trusts, that distinction becomes more important. The organisations that transform teaching over the next decade will not do so through sophisticated platforms alone. They will be the ones whose leaders keep asking what their technology is actually showing them, and who build the culture, courage and shared language required to ask that question honestly, together, especially when the data suggests an answer that feels a little too easy.

See clearly. Act proportionately. Improve deliberately.

Research Table

SectionTheory / ConceptKey References
The Familiar Shape of the ProblemOrganisational coherence; fragmented improvement activityFullan and Quinn (2016); Bryk et al. (2015)
The Visibility TrapJudgement under uncertainty; metric fixationKahneman (2011); Muller (2018)
The Trust That Saw Too Much, Too SoonCalibration; trust; professional dialogueWiliam (2011); Kahneman (2011); Bryk and Schneider (2002)
The Vehicle and the DriverClimate vs culture; psychological safety; feedback as adjustmentSchein (2010); Bryk and Schneider (2002); Edmondson (1999, 2019); Hattie and Timperley (2007)
Clarity Before TechnologyPedagogical knowledge; shared language; organisational learningShulman (1987); Biesta (2013); Senge (2006); Hattie and Timperley (2007)
From Judgement to EnquiryDisciplined inquiry; improvement science; proportionate responseBryk et al. (2015); Argyris and Schön (1978)
What This Means for the Trust You LeadDistributed leadership; coherence at scaleFullan (2016); Fullan and Quinn (2016); Spillane (2006)

Reference List

Argyris, C. and Schön, D. A. (1978) Organizational Learning: A Theory of Action Perspective. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.

Biesta, G. (2013) The Beautiful Risk of Education. Boulder, CO: Paradigm.

Bryk, A. S. and Schneider, B. (2002) Trust in Schools: A Core Resource for Improvement. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

Bryk, A. S., Gomez, L. M., Grunow, A. and LeMahieu, P. G. (2015) Learning to Improve: How America’s Schools Can Get Better at Getting Better. Cambridge, MA: Harvard Education Press.

Edmondson, A. C. (1999) ‘Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams’, Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), pp. 350–383.

Edmondson, A. C. (2019) The Fearless Organization. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.

Fullan, M. (2016) The New Meaning of Educational Change. 5th edn. London: Routledge.

Fullan, M. and Quinn, J. (2016) Coherence: The Right Drivers in Action for Schools, Districts, and Systems. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin.

Hattie, J. and Timperley, H. (2007) ‘The power of feedback’, Review of Educational Research, 77(1), pp. 81–112.

Kahneman, D. (2011) Thinking, Fast and Slow. London: Penguin.

Muller, J. Z. (2018) The Tyranny of Metrics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

Schein, E. H. (2010) Organizational Culture and Leadership. 4th edn. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Senge, P. M. (2006) The Fifth Discipline: The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization. Rev. edn. London: Random House.

Shulman, L. S. (1987) ‘Knowledge and teaching: foundations of the new reform’, Harvard Educational Review, 57(1), pp. 1–22.

Spillane, J. P. (2006) Distributed Leadership. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Wiliam, D. (2011) Embedded Formative Assessment. Bloomington, IN: Solution Tree.

The Value of Curiosity

One of the privileges of preparing for TransforMATive LIVE: Sweden has been the opportunity to spend time in Stockholm, visit schools, speak with education leaders and begin to understand the system from the inside rather than from a distance.



What struck me most was not any single policy, technology or classroom practice. It was the value of stepping outside our own context.

In England, it is very easy to become absorbed by the immediate pressures of the system: accountability, attendance, funding, recruitment, workload, digital strategy and the pace of AI adoption. Those challenges are real, but they can also narrow our field of vision.

Being in Stockholm created a different kind of space.

Conversations with Swedish education leaders offered a perspective shaped by a different culture, policy environment and relationship with technology. Engaging with superintendents from the United States added another dimension again: different governance, different terminology, different constraints, but often remarkably familiar questions about pupils, teachers, leadership and the role technology should play.

That is where curiosity becomes powerful.

The value of international exchange is not in searching for a model that can simply be imported into another system. Context matters too much for that. The real value comes from asking better questions.

Why do you do it that way?

What problem were you trying to solve?

What has worked?

What has not?

What would you change if you were starting again?

And, perhaps most importantly: what assumptions in our own system have we stopped noticing because they feel normal to us?

That same mindset matters in the age of AI.

Technology can increasingly provide us with answers at extraordinary speed. It can summarise, analyse, recommend and generate. But leadership still requires the curiosity to interrogate those answers, seek alternative perspectives and understand the context behind them.

There is a risk that greater access to information makes us less inclined to explore.

For me, experiences like TransforMATive LIVE: Sweden are a deliberate counterbalance to that.

They create space to observe schools directly, hear from people working in different systems, compare perspectives and return to our own organisations with new questions rather than borrowed solutions.

To Connect is not simply to meet more people. It is to expose ourselves to perspectives that challenge our own, to make connections between ideas and to remain curious enough to reconsider what we think we already know.

The most valuable outcome of an international leadership exchange is therefore unlikely to be a list of things to replicate.

It is the moment when somebody else’s experience causes you to look at your own organisation differently.

And sometimes that question, rather than the answer, is where transformation begins.

Why school trusts need a connected operational ecosystem

Ask any teacher what they’re there to do and they will all clearly tell you, ‘Give every student the time, attention and education they need.’ Everything about how schools train, resource and support teaching staff is built around that single purpose. It’s why we obsess over class sizes, planning time, CPD, and workload reviews, because the entire system exists to protect a teacher’s ability to make an impact in front of students.

Now ask the same question of the finance director, the procurement lead, or the business manager sitting three floors up in the trust’s central team. Their answer is just as clear: make sure the money, the contracts, the data, and the decisions behind the scenes are working as hard as possible for the schools they serve. Their contribution may be less visible to pupils day to day, but it is no less important to whether a trust thrives or merely survives.

The challenge is that the systems and support available to these teams have not always evolved at the same pace. We’ve spent a decade building systems, training, and cultural expectations that maximise a teacher’s impact. Across finance, procurement, operations and data, investment has often been more uneven, leaving central teams to work around fragmented processes and technology while expectations continue to increase.

Instead, too many teams are still stitching together multiple systems to overcome single, isolated problems, from spreadsheets to legacy accounting, compliance, contracts, and accounts payable automation, with systems that often do not integrate effectively. At the same time, they are making six-figure purchasing decisions without always having timely, joined-up information available at the point those decisions are made.

This is one of the gaps that this year’s ‘Connect’, the TransforMATive Digital Leadership Summit, is highlighting. Digital change in education has too often been approached in silos: one project for the MIS, another for cyber, another for finance, often with limited integration between them and all competing for the same stretched central team’s attention.

What connected can look like: P2P within a wider operational ecosystem

I’d argue what MATs actually need isn’t another disconnected point solution. They need a connected operational ecosystem in which finance, procurement, people, data and technology can work together, while specialist platforms continue to do what they do best.

Within that wider ecosystem, a unified procure-to-pay (P2P) framework can provide an important connective layer between purchasing decisions, approvals, suppliers and financial information. Done well, it can help surface critical trust data to key staff when they need to make a decision, rather than several weeks later at month-end.

And this is where AI can actually earn its place. I personally see this as an augmentation of education professionals, supporting the less visible work of surfacing the right number, flagging the right anomaly, or drafting the first cut of an analysis, so the human making the decision has better information a lot faster.

Education leaders are rightly cautious about anything that looks like AI replacing judgement; safeguarding and trust are too central to how schools work for that caution to be misplaced. The right framing isn’t AI-driven. It’s human-led and AI-augmented. Accountability stays exactly where it is; the effort required to get good information in front of the right person is simply reduced.

The part that requires a collective, not a single vendor

Beyond information sharing, if done well, this connected transparency can also create value in a broader way. For example, why should a three-school trust pay more for the same goods and services than a thirty-school trust down the road?

The short answer is often size and scale. Larger trusts with greater spending power can typically negotiate better pricing, better terms, and stronger supplier relationships. This means the MATs with the least capacity to negotiate are often the ones paying the most.

That’s not a systems problem any single trust can fix by buying better software alone. It is something the sector can begin to address when trusts, suppliers and the wider sector connect around models that create greater transparency and collective purchasing power, potentially through something closer to a shared marketplace, with comparable pricing and terms accessible to trusts regardless of size.

That’s the real test of ‘Connect’ as a theme. It’s easy to agree that silos are bad. It’s harder to build something that depends on organisations that do not currently work together choosing to collaborate. A shared procurement model across MATs of every size is exactly that kind of collective effort, and it’s precisely the sort of ambition a Summit like this one exists to explore with the leaders, practitioners and partners who could help make it happen.

Philip Douglas, CEO, Compleat Software

With over two decades of leadership across the technology and SaaS sectors, Philip Douglas brings a unique blend of financial expertise and technology-driven vision to the forefront of digital transformation. As CEO of Compleat Software, he has built a platform that empowers businesses to streamline procurement and finance operations through intelligent automation, seamless integration, and user-friendly design.

Compleat Software

Since 2008, Compleat has been helping schools digitise the entire purchasing process with online purchasing software, allowing all departments to submit purchase requisitions with automated approval workflows based on your chosen criteria, giving finance teams full oversight and control over future cash requirements.

Written by:

Phil Douglas (CEO)